Harly, please make a code documentation as to what exactly is missing in the theme.php. Complaints about an AddOn's approval is best handled at Next, I think, we have no obvious way of handling that yet, but if this Theme was approved despite existing errors, no one stands to gain on it. We all loose.
I am locking this, pending a thread at Next. I am EXPECTING a thread at Next or this will remain locked, and I will, somehow, remove the approval. Gentlemen, prepare your material and documentation as to why this theme should be approved and why it should not.
Harly, may I suggest you start the discussion, since you brought up this issue? Please make sure Sitemaster and Assensvej are there to answer your questions.
Craig, I need to point out that we do have a forum for complaints, that is VERY true, but those complaints are firstly for Moderation of the Forums. You indicate right, a complaint should be handled elsewhere, but this issue is not about Moderation, hence I deem Next to be a better place for this.
@Harly: If you have an issue with a member of the Addons approvers Team please use the Site & Forum Issues board or feel free to contact a member of Management.
I do agree with the others on the design part: Good idea, and nice look! :)
But: First of all, this is not made for 7.02 - the new codes and the new comment function are missing from the theme.php. (BTW: I've made a step by step guide about this: Guide: 7.01 - 7.02 theme.php changes) Second of all, the validation of the theme's XHTML shows 13 errors. The CSS is 100% valid, though. The structure of the rar-file is a little wrong too - when you open the .rar, the first thing you should see, is the themes folder, the Extra folder, the agpl license and the readme-en.html - not a folder on top of those!
Sure, you did'nt upload the old version of the theme by mistake, Kenneth?
@SiteMaster - You're the approver. Tell me: Don't you even check what you're approving? :( You could have spared Kenneth for this embarrassment. :@